Unexplainable Pain That Comes From Nowhere

Understanding functional and nervous system pain.

Personal Note

I am someone who had to dive deep into research and physiology because the standard medical answers weren’t working for my unexplainable pain.

My journey began when a doctor recommended taking cold showers, a wellness trend that backfired. Applying cold water to my torso triggered acute pain in my chest and upper back, leaving my system so sensitized that, for months, even a light draft could cause muscle pain.

I tried a physical therapist’s massage and a laser treatment, but both left me significantly worse. Conversely, my old chiropractor gave me simple advice: “Stay away from the cold.”

When no one could find anything wrong with me structurally and my tests came back normal, I began researching. The information in this article is a synthesis of data across neurology, orthopedics and behavioral medicine, with insights from a psychologist and my own history of trial and error. I wrote this to explain why standard advice often fails.

This Article at a Glance

Pain That Comes From Nowhere

Many people live with physical pain that seems to have no clear cause. The pain is real, sometimes intense, sometimes shifting and often slow to resolve.

Tests come back normal. Imaging shows nothing alarming. Common explanations like arthritis, rheumatoid arthritis, autoimmune disease or fibromyalgia have already been ruled out. Yet the pain continues and is often dismissed as stress or labeled as something psychological.

That dismissal leaves people confused and stuck without explanation, but there may be another way to understand what’s happening.

When Pain Is Real but the Tests Are Normal

Pain does not require visible tissue damage to exist. Pain can persist because of changes in muscle tone, connective tissue tension, circulation and nervous system signaling, even when scans look normal.

This does not mean the pain is imagined. It means the source is functional rather than structural. The system involved is not a joint or an organ alone, but the way the body regulates stress, recovery and safety. That system is the nervous system.

Because this type of pain sits at the intersection of several medical fields, you may encounter different terms depending on whether you are speaking to a neurologist, a psychologist or a physical therapist.

Common names for this experience include:
Functional Pain: Focused on how the system functions rather than its structure.
Nervous System Pain: A general term for pain driven by the regulatory systems of the body.
Nociplastic Pain: The clinical term for pain caused by altered nervous system signaling.
Central Sensitization: When the central nervous system stays in a persistent state of high reactivity.
Psychosomatic Pain: A term used in behavioral medicine to describe the interaction between mental state and physical symptoms.

A Simple Explanation of the Nervous System

The nervous system is the body’s communication and control network. It constantly monitors what is happening inside and outside the body and adjusts functions that keep us alive and responsive.

It regulates things like heart rate, breathing, digestion, muscle tension, blood pressure, temperature response and recovery without conscious effort.

One part of this system is called the autonomic nervous system. This is the branch that works automatically in the background. Its role is regulation. It helps the body respond to challenges and then return to baseline once the challenge passes.

When regulation works well, the body adapts and recovers. When it does not, the system stays activated longer than it should.

Autonomic Dysregulation

Autonomic dysregulation, sometimes referred to as autonomic dysfunction or dysautonomia, describes a state in which the body’s fight or flight response becomes the default setting. This response is designed to protect us in moments of danger by mobilizing energy, increasing alertness and preparing the body for action. Normally, once the threat passes, the nervous system shifts out of fight or flight and returns the body to a regulated baseline.

When the nervous system is dysregulated, pain often shows up in the body’s weakest or most vulnerable area at that moment. This may be a previously injured spot, an area under chronic tension or a region temporarily stressed by posture, strain or cold. The nervous system does not choose the location randomly; it amplifies signals where the body has the least capacity to compensate at that time.

When this shift back to baseline does not happen efficiently, the system remains in a heightened defensive mode. The nervous system stays on guard even when no immediate threat is present.

It is important to note that autonomic dysregulation does not express itself only through pain. Pain is often what brings people to look for answers, but dysregulation can also show up as fatigue, sleep disruption, vertigo, digestive symptoms, temperature intolerance, heart rate changes or a general sense that the body is not well. Pain is not the only expression.

This state does not require a single dramatic event. It often develops gradually, especially in people who are sensitive, under prolonged stress, recovering from illness or dealing with repeated physical or emotional strain. When regulation falters, muscle tone can remain elevated, connective tissue tightens, pain thresholds drop and recovery takes longer than expected. The symptoms are physical, even though no structural injury is present.

Why This Can Become More Pronounced With Age and High Sensitivity

Autonomic dysregulation often becomes more noticeable after midlife and in highly sensitive people (HSPs), because the body has less margin for stress.

With age, muscle tone, strength and recovery capacity tend to decline, especially in people who move less or do not regularly engage their muscles. Muscle tissue is not only about movement, it also provides structural support, thermal buffering and steady feedback to the nervous system. When that buffering capacity is reduced, cold exposure, physical strain or prolonged tension can place a higher load on regulation.

In highly sensitive people, sensory input and internal signals are already processed more intensely, which further narrows the margin for recovery.

The nervous system compensates by staying on guard longer, increasing muscle tone and protective signaling. Over time, this can make dysregulation easier to trigger and slower to resolve, even in people who appear otherwise healthy and strong.

Stacked Stressors and Delayed Symptoms

One of the most confusing aspects of this pattern is timing. A physical strain, an awkward movement, exposure to cold or drafts, emotional pressure or anticipation may each be tolerable on their own. When they overlap, the nervous system can tip into dysregulation.

These overlapping inputs are often referred to as stacked stressors. The body is managing more than one demand at the same time without enough recovery in between.

Symptoms may not appear immediately. Pain can show up hours or even days later. This delay makes the connection easy to miss and easy for others to dismiss. Yet delayed symptoms are common when the nervous system is involved.

Psychosomatic Does Not Mean Imaginary

In some fields such as psychology and behavioral medicine, symptoms like these are often categorized as psychosomatic. However the word psychosomatic is frequently misunderstood. It is commonly taken to mean that symptoms are all in your head, which is not accurate.

Psychosomatic simply refers to the interaction between mind and body. It acknowledges that emotional states, perception and nervous system signaling influence physical symptoms.

That does not mean the symptoms are unreal. It means the body is responding to signals that involve both psychological and physiological processes. In autonomic dysregulation, the body is reacting to perceived threat or overload even when there is no visible damage. The result is real pain, real tension and real dysfunction.

Why Common Advice Helps Some People and Hurts Others

Many approaches to nervous system regulation genuinely help some people. Breathing practices, vagus nerve focused techniques, massage, cold exposure such as cold plunges and supplements such as magnesium can be beneficial and stabilizing for certain nervous systems.

Highly sensitive people (HSPs), people under prolonged stress, those recovering from illness or injury or individuals whose nervous systems are already highly reactive may experience increased symptoms when they add more stimulation, even if that stimulation is considered therapeutic.

In this context, anxiety often plays a role, especially when symptoms are unexplained and the outcome feels uncertain. This ongoing vigilance keeps the nervous system on guard and becomes another stressor. Anxiety is not the root cause, but it can act as fuel on an already unstable system and amplify symptoms.

Cold Sensitivity and Over Reactive Systems

Cold exposure such as cold plunges, cold showers, ice baths or applying cold water to the face is sometimes used to influence stress response and autonomic activity. For some people, this can be helpful. For others, especially those with over reactive systems, cold exposure can lead to more pain, increased tension, delayed flares and prolonged recovery.

Cold sensitivity is not a lack of resilience, it is a signal that the nervous system does not need more challenge, it needs less. Ignoring this distinction can make symptoms significantly worse.

Regulation Is the Goal

For over reactive systems, regulation is the goal and it cannot be accomplished by pushing through.
Pushing the system with more stimulation, more intensity or more exposure often adds to the load instead of reducing it.

Regulation comes from creating conditions in which the nervous system can safely return to baseline.
This includes reducing stacked stressors, meaning limiting the overlap of physical strain, sensory input, emotional pressure and recovery demands.

Predictability, warmth, pacing physical effort, limiting stacked stressors and allowing sufficient recovery time are often more effective than interventions aimed at stimulation.

What Improvement Actually Means

Improvement does not necessarily mean eliminating all triggers or living cautiously forever. It means raising the threshold at which the system overreacts and shortening the duration of flares when they occur.

Autonomic dysregulation is manageable for many people. Whether it is fully reversible depends on the individual, their circumstances and how long the system has been under strain. What matters most is recognition. When the condition is understood as physiological rather than minimized as anxiety or weakness, people can make choices that support recovery instead of undermining it.

Final Thoughts

Understanding that my unexplainable pain was functional rather than structural changed everything for me. It stopped the cycle of seeking ‘fixes’ that only made me worse and allowed me to start working with my nervous system instead of against it.

If you are in the middle of this struggle, know that your pain is real and your body is not failing you. It is protecting you, perhaps too vigilantly. Recovery is not about finding one miracle treatment; it is about slowly proving to your nervous system that it is safe to stand down. It takes time, patience and a shift in how we listen to our bodies, but it is a path that finally leads somewhere meaningful.

Disclaimer: This article is for informational purposes only and may include curated or personal content. It is not medical advice. Please consult a licensed provider before making health decisions.

If you’re exploring more ways to stay healthy, you may also like:

• Which Pain Reliever Is Safest for People Over 50?
• How to Use Artificial IntelligenceI to Manage your Health
• Types of Alternative Medicine: What They Do and How to Choose
• What it Means to be a Highly Sensitive Person (HSP)

Download or Print the Cheat Sheet

Unexplainable Pain That Comes From Nowhere

Explore Related Topics